Make a list of all the characters in your icons. (Although you may have more than one icon of a single character, they only go on the list once.) Alphabetize it. Take the first two people on the list; that's
your first pairing. Second two people; second pairing, etc.
Note: I did not alphabetize by last name. Suck it up.
Angela Graynamore (Joe vs. The Volcano)/Banky (Chasing Amy, etc.) - I can see Banky using Angela
Ben Hawkins/Binah - *blush* I can say no more because I'm a married woman!
Boober Fraggle/Bucky - Ohhh, I don't think so...
Cookie Monster/Gandalf - I think my brain just exploded.
George Carlin/Jesus - OTP! OTP! OTP!
Jon Stewart/Llama llama duck - Hmm...
Metatron/Mulder - I don't think Mulder believes in the Metatron, so I'm thinking that's a big NO
Nani (Lilo&Stitch)/Randall (Clerks) - I think Nani would kick Randall's ass
Rob Corddry/Saddam - OTP! OTP! OTP! Well, not REALLY...
Spiderman/Stephen Colbert - It's FRENCH, bitch...
Stitch/Strong Bad - Heh. Strong Bad will get his ass kicked.
T'Pol/Ted Hitler - Oh, I don't think so...
The Tick/Trip - Switch this and the last pairing to Trip/T'Pol and The Tick/Ted Hitler, and then we'd be cooking with gas.
Wembly Fraggle/Ymza in kitten form (Emperor's New Groove) - No, no, no...
Ohh, I left out Inigo Montoyo and Silent Bob! Fuck it, I'm done. Besides, it'll screw up my favorite pairing of George Carlin and Jesus, so there!